Totally Should’ve Book Tag

'Totally Should've'Book Tag

I have seen this tag going around Booktube so I was so happy when Meghan from Meghan’s Whimsical Exploration and Reviews tagged me!

1. Totally Should’ve Gotten A Sequel


This is a hard one for me since I love standalones but I would love a sequel to I’ll Give You the Sun by Jandy Nelson.  I think that the story wrapped up nicely, but it would still be great to see what happens to Noah and Jude in the future.

2. Totally Should’ve Gotten A Spin-Off Series

Image result for to all the boys i've loved before sisters

Again this is a hard one because I have not read a lot of series! A spin-off series to All the Boys I’ve Loved Before might be fun! I adore Lara Jean’s younger sister, Kitty, and would love a series based on her high school experience!

3. An Author Who Should Write More Books

Image result for khaled hosseini books

Khaled Hosseini is an autobuy author for me and he hasn’t published a book since 2012!! I am not sure if he plans on writing another novel or not but I really hope so.  He is a true literary genius!

4. A Character Who Totally Should’ve Ended Up With Someone Else

Image result for harry and luna

I have said this so many times but Harry Potter should have ended up with Luna Lovegood! I also think Katniss should have either ended up with Gale or alone.

5. Totally Should’ve Had A Movie Franchise


Could you imagine an Illuminae movie? That would be so EPIC! This needs to happen.

6. Totally Should’ve Kept The Original Covers

Image result for the diviners cover change

Hmm… I normally enjoy the cover changes more than the original covers! I like the new covers for The Diviners but I still think I prefer the original! It is more intriguing and I really like the background.

7. Totally Should’ve Stopped At Book One

Image result for divergent

I am going to go with Divergent.  I really did enjoy Divergent but then it all went down hill after that.  I would have been much happier if the story wrapped up nicely in book one.

I Tag:

Books and Belle

The Book Raven

Whimsy Pages


Do you agree or disagree with any of my answers? I would love to know a cover change that you did not like since I struggled with that question!


40 thoughts on “Totally Should’ve Book Tag

  1. YES to all of these!! I’ll give you the sun could have continued. I loved those characters so much I wanted more of their lives!
    I’ve had A Thousand Splendid Suns on my shelves for YEARS and I really need to just read it already!
    And…… ILLUMINAE NEEDS A MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!
    Great list 🙂

  2. Oh, this looks so fun! 💜 Lovely answers to a lovely tag, Kristin! A cover change that I wasn’t a fan of would be Shatter Me; I liked the paperback far more than the hardcover. 🙂

  3. i would cry for a THOUSAND YEARS if i’ll give you the sun got a sequel oh my god. i love that book SO MUCH, need more noah and jude! great post!

  4. I’m so glad you did this tag! 😀 I agree with you 100% Luna and Harry should have ended up together. They are so cute together! I also agree with Divergent. The series kept going downhill from the first book!

  5. This is such a cool tag, omg. Totally agree with the sequel to I’ll Give You The Sun, I just read it this year and I’d love to see either a sequel or a prequel. So much untapped potential there!

  6. Ahhh I would LOVE to read more of Jude and Noah’s lives! I’ll Give You the Sun was such an incredible book. And ooh getting a spin-off of the Lara Jean trilogy would be super super cute, especially getting Kitty’s POV! <3 Lovely choices, Kristin!

  7. Oh my! A lit professor just recommended me Khaled Hosseini books a few days ago! and she gave me a copy of the three books!

    Thank you for making such a great tag! I am even more into reading the books!

      1. I hope so, and I think I will haha She said that you cannot literally put them down! So I still have my own challenge to complete, but I will do my best XD

  8. Great answers, Kristin 🌸
    Totally agree that Divergent should’ve stopped at book one; I didn’t even complete the series the first time round! Also YES to Harry and Luna, I really really think they would’ve been perfect together!

  9. Oh fantastic answes for this tag, Kristin! I loved I’ll Give You The Sun as a standalone, but since it’s one of my favorite books, I can’t help but being a bit curious as well when it comes to Noah and Jude’s future….a next book would be great ahah 🙂 AND YES for the spin-off about Kitty – this would be SO amazing. She was probably one of my favorite characters in the series 🙂
    An Illuminae-movie would be very cool – but I don’t think I’d watch it, I already had the chills while READING the book, 😂😂

      1. It makes me glad that I bought my copy of The Diviners from Book Outlet so I didn’t spend a lot of money on it. I’ll just buy the whole trilogy with the new covers and be happy.

Leave a Reply